Originally Posted by
kettle1
Based on that description it was Bill Clinton, George Clooney, Steve Martin, Harrison Ford, Matt LeBlanc, John Slattery, Jamie Lee Curtis

or Roseanne Barr.

Bill Clinton - too tall
George Clooney - too dark
Steve Martin - too old
Harrison Ford - too old
Matt LeBlanc - too young
Jamie Lee Curtis - wrong gender
Roseanne Barr - maybe that's it!