I stayed at Hiiragiya for one night in the expectation that it would offer a "unique cultural experience". I am afraid that although a very pleasant stay, my expectations were far too ambitious. You can read my report here if you have not done so already: http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/luxur...ncy-kyoto.html

In particular, you may want to note my observation from my report, that "I would however not ever consider staying at a Ryokan again, as it was really somewhat underwhelming due to my extraordinary high expectations of a virtual time machine back to the Edo era".

To me, at the end of the day, the experience consisted of a very isolating time in spartan accommodations at a very high price. That being said, I understand the attraction of wanting to "experience" it, and that is precisely why I stayed there. Mission accomplished.