Ridefar thanks for posting this!
Mrs. Travelsig and I have been thinking of going here for a few years and I have a friend living in St. Johns which makes for a nice trip. We hesitated until now- I think your report will result in a visit from us next year.
Appreciate the detail.
One question- is there anywhere else to eat on the Island (worth visiting) besides the hotel? If so- then the full board option is probably not that interesting. If not- then it is more compelling.