Originally Posted by MPH1980

I'd actually say the forum is under constant change. The allusions to Mucci and Pucci (which - I agree - I've still no idea what the heck that's all about) are largely gone for example.

The point I'm attempting to make is against those who simply say 'TRs are in the TR forum' - having rules that are enforced no matter what - particularly for engaging content like this which was appropriate for this forum will make this place less interesting. It's a paper cut - but enough of them really hurt.

I also frequent the MoneySavingExpert site. I've virtually stopped visiting due to a lack of interesting threads. A login to the credit card forum will guarantee a mix of threads - several 'which credit card is right for me' (without any detail on their situation) - several 'I've been ripped off' (when they haven't) and probably one 'can I claim on section 75 for this' query. Seeing that combination every day/week gets boring.

There will be an occasional thread on a new credit card. That's of interest - but it's occasional.

A lack of engaging content means I've stopped going and I'll miss that thread that is of interest.

I think the moderators here do a very good job of keeping the BA forum clean and bringing in queries from other forums to this one. I just, personally, think this call was a bad one and stifled an interesting thread.