Originally Posted by
uszkanni
A generous tip, I'm sure she appreciated it greatly.
In higher priced establishments I expect a higher level of service and the service level that justified a 20% tip in my local taco joint might not hack it at some upscale eatery. TBS,
I still don't get why a $100 tip on a $500 bill for service that didn't go above and beyond would be considered insufficient. Perhaps he was confused about the bill or having a really bad day or couldn't believe that you were using cash instead of a miles earning CC.

I guess we'll never know but, in any case, his attitude could have used some adjustment. Had I seen such a change in disposition I might have asked if there was some problem and had his reaction to the tip amount been a bit more overt and/or the least bit derisive I would have spoken to the manager.
I don't get why a $100 tip on a $500 bill for service that went above and beyond would be considered insufficient. Perhaps not overly generous...but when did a 20% tip become substandard. Is the 15%-20% range no longer the guideline?