Originally Posted by
oshelef
How much do you have to underpack to fit the timbuk2 messenger? ...so you'd have to make sure the messenger is packed flat... but for conference and such, I don't like the messenger style as much.
Are there amazon basics ones that aren't padded? I kind of don't want the padded laptop focused bag ... The laptop doesn't need built in protection - I tend to use a thin neoprene sleeve ...
Quick answer, not by much - if at all. I sometimes take out the iPad or tablet to reduce bulk.
The key deciding factor is how & where you plan to bring that personal bag or day bag into (and, certainly not the board room, etc. - trade shows & conferences are fine for me) - I would go with a basic black one. Assumed that you are using the Motherlode TLS 22" Convertible - if & when it is not overpacked & overstuffed, there's plenty of space to fit a messenger bag or any soft-sided shoulder bag on the outside compartment, without excessive compression with the straps - or make it bulky like a whale. My Bag is a smaller one that will fit, very tightly, a Sony Viao 11.6" netbook prefered on most trips (over the 14" Dell) - the "package" is about 3.5" thick - it's smaller than a medium eBag packing cube (loved them & have plenty of them to mix-n-match)
The "S" Classic Bag will easily compress to fit and should be ideal for the MB - just double check the specs. I used nylon/zip pouches to keep some items together, so it's quick & easy to move them around before boarding or after hitting the terminal off the jetbridge - while the TLS stayed in the OH bin in-flight. The tablet is usually all I need for shorter flights along with inline earbuds. I also use a neoprene sleeve for the netbook/notebook, especially when storing it in the "hidden" back compartable to keep them in near new conditions and avoid scratches. Pack your contents into a medium packing tube, it will slip easily right inside the U-shaped zipped section and disappear.
Check eBay for deals, should be pleasantly surprised to find a pre-owned or even new ones without tags for as much as 50% off retail pricing. But, there are times & places where it called for using the good old Coach Beekman briefcase. For urban/weekend errands, the Bag is a better fit vs. shouldering a STM laptop/messenger or other "high profile" ones that draw attention to what's inside.