Welcome to Flyertalk, and congratulations on your upcoming anniversary.

You need to account for travel time too. Costa Rica is a small country with a difficult highway system. Once you get here, you'll see. Papagayo to Arenal will eat up a huge chunk of a day. Arenal to Manuel Antonio will eat up a huge chunk of another day. Your 3-3-4 isn't going to be anywhere near 3, 3, and 4 full days at these places.