Without knowing much about AA's award routing rules, I think there are more options available than it shows in the calendar.

For example, 11/18-11/23 for 2.

1 readily viewable option for the outbound on 11/18, FAT-SEA-OGG.

On the return, only a 2-stop AS/AS/AS with an overnight in PDX I think shows. However using the AS award calendar, saver space is available OGG-SAN-FAT with an overnight in SAN leaving 11/23. It's a much nicer routing, but will only price out on AA's multi-city award search with an extra cost 17.5+17.5+12.5 p/p, though you'd still have enough to cover it if you can't get it to price out as just a r/t instead of multi-city.

AS's OGG-SAN-FAT with the overnight pops up a number of times (via the AS calendar) during your whole search period too, I know the Thanksgiving dates weren't wanted, but it's just an example.