I stayed at RC last year and it's a great location. Staff is great, view from room is gorgeous and 24hr hot tub/pools are awesome.
RC is more expensive than other properties but it is also most private! Frenchman's Cove is very close to port so beaches are open to tourists from cruise ships. My trip to STT was during peak-season and cruise ships can bring 25000-30000 tourists per day. A small island becomes quite a nuisance with that kind of extra crowd. Stay away from Charlotte Amelie and you'll be happy.
-Resort fee is $50 and good value IMO. It includes cost of getting life-jackets, sail boats, snorkel gear etc.
-Food/drinks on the property are expensive but Red Hook isn't much cheaper either. They are all priced to make a buck off the tourists.
-Car is not required but if you plan to leave property often, that might work cheaper.
-Rooms are spacious, clean, and have a gorgeous view (get a balcony room)!
If this is an award getaway, it's worth every point.