Originally Posted by
ZZYZXROAD
Been to the USVI many times and I can honestly tell you USVI is very overrated unless you sail. There are much better destinations and this hotel is very overrated and over priced. Don't even bother to rent a car as there is nothing to drive to, not like Hawaii or Cali. Grab a cab to Charlotte Amalie for the day and enjoy some cheezy cruise ship shops with average prices and products. Other than that, no need to leave the resort. Most of the island isn't safe and I've seen goats slaughtered in the street on the way to this hotel as well.
100% completely disagree on almost all points made by
ZZYZXROAD.
The USVI are fantastic to visit for numerous reasons that are detailed elsewhere. I personally love STT as it has most of the activity, restaurants, and nightlife. However, STJ has some gorgeous beaches and picturesque landscapes (as well as great restaurants: try Fatty Crab).
The main reason some people dislike STT is that they stay at places like the Marriott, or other hotels close to Charlotte Amalie. The downtown of Charlotte Amalie is good for a short day visit. Check out some shops, have lunch, etc. There are usually 5-15k cruise ship passengers downtown. I prefer to avoid it. The East End of STT, especially Red Hook, is about a 30min drive through rolling, windy hills that tease a sense of thrill and danger as you drive on the left side of the road. Most people either don't know, or don't have the time to go to the East End...which is where the Ritz is excellently located.
Not renting a car and staying at the resort is a big waste of an opportunity. In addition, I would AVOID Charlotte Amalie as that is were the traffic and throngs of unruly cruise ship passengers stay. Get out and visit some of the smaller, quiet beaches on the east end, and eat at some of the local restaurants in Red Hook.
Lastly, the island is very safe. I've lived there for many years and have never, EVER had an issue. Conversely, yes - there is crime - similar to most islands. Sometimes it can be violent, but common sense prevails and you will be fine. Enjoy.