As mentioned in my op, I'll have Platinum status at time of stay from the credit card, so I will definitely ask for an upgrade at the Madeline. My employer won't pay for the deluxe or premier room there (I should check and see how much extra it woud be out of pocket).

FD1971: I would be able to get a club king at the Etoile, which is why I was wondering if the enhanced room benefits made up for the hotel itself...