Originally Posted by deadinabsentia

Neither. They are both average at best, and their properties are old and run down.
If this is something you do regularly then go for it, its cheap digs. If going to Hawaii is a one of for you, I'd look elsewhere.

Its wasteful to spend all your time and money to do something average.

Have a brilliant trip. Do Fairmont or Four Seasons.. or perhaps even home away. We rented a great house in Lahina last time for less than a room at Westin. Private pool and 5 minutes to the beach.