Your post got me thinking and I will be trying this restaurant when I am there next week:
http://citytavern.com/
Can't get much more historic than this:
http://citytavern.com/history1.html
Solid reviews online as well. Not sure when your trip is but I can let you know how the place is if you would like.
Last edited by Consultette; Jan 20, 2014 at 8:14 am