Originally Posted by
eponymous_coward
Why is it "insulting" to charge for a good or service that presumably has value? Sounds a bit entitled to assume that you should be given elite status based on DYWKIA. Some airlines grant status matches, some challenge, some charge for a challenge. Doesn't seem "insulting" if policies are standardized and people and businesses can choose what works for them.
Maybe I am just more sensitive than others
If one can document his/her flying history and wants to bring his/her business to US, it is pretty crazy to ask a new customer for $200 to try US.
Of course, the problem is with people gaming the system. So, maybe a free challenge system (no status until challenge is met) is the easiest, followed by a refundable fee system.