Not sure this thread is the right place, so if the mods want to move this question or create a new thread, go ahead.

So, has anybody been to both Amanpulo and Amanyara and can offer up detailed comparison? Specifically: quality of beach (sure pulo wins this one, but tell me what you think), food and dining options and quality, quality of service, hard product, quality of sea life and coral for snorkeling, overall impressions? I have been to Amanpulo three times now, and my past rave reviews still apply--it is the best Aman I have been to for both service and location/hard product. How does Amanyara compare?