FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Impact of US/AA merger to United fliers
View Single Post
Old Aug 24, 2013 | 4:44 pm
  #748  
jkburns1
 
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: PWM/MHT/BOS
Programs: UA (lame duck)1K, US Plat,HHonors Diamond, PC Plat, SPG Plat, MR Platinum
Posts: 605
Originally Posted by BearX220
It's worth noting that MHT airline operations have declined dramatically since the latest round of industry consolidation began. Departures declined 45 percent 2007-2012; passengers down 37 percent 2005-2011.

http://www.unionleader.com/article/2...887&source=RSS

This is somewhat because the "Southwest effect" (that drove the initial boom at MHT, and major airport expansion) has been blunted, partly by Southwest opening BOS as well, also because Southwest isn't such a low-price leader any more in general. It's also owing to mergers, and airlines cutting back in marginal markets. NW opened MSP-MHT before it was merged away, and DL operated CVG-MHT. United used to have mainline service to ORD. Those flights and many more are gone now, and MHT has hardly any mainline service outside of the Southwest 737s.

It's almost all Barbie jets, and as you wander the deserted, unused concourses with the blank gate screens and jetways gathering dust, it's sad to think about the boom this airport was built for that has now died off thanks in part to the mergers.

PWM is in similar straits. The airport was expanded within the last ten years but today it looks like a huge misstep. Last time I landed there in a DL RJ, at mid-morning, we were literally the only commercial aircraft on the field.

BTV has always struggled.

My point is that I think it's incredibly wishful thinking, perhaps naive, to imagine that AA/US would lead to more flights out of underserved airports like these, or that UA would respond with more service. As we all know, UA thinks the road to success is with less service, less capacity... and the evidence in general is that mergers don't lead to more flights to more places, they lead to less.

I take an interest in northern New England air service (AA doesn't)... I used to live there and still fly back a lot. MHT used to represent a major price advantage versus BOS, like BWI over DCA. Not anymore.

I don't think PWM has declined like MHT has. They just expanded PWM (not particularly sure why) but at least with PWM if you live close to or north of it BOS is not competition like it is for MHT due to the 2+ hr drive being so prohibitive. MHT has done some incredibly stupid things - like ramping up garage parking to $16 (or is it $18) a day, buying out the closest offsite parking (Highlander lot) so they couldn't offer competitive rates and a quicker shuttle then the long term parking shuttle hassle etc.
I can park at preflight near BOS for less than that and you rarely can find a fare out of MHT that's less then it would be from BOS (at least PWM has left it at $10 or $12). Only advantage is the traffic in and out, quicker security gates into the ghosttown and getting off the tarmac quicker.

Further consolidation and mergers are far more likely to result in the closure of an MHT or PWM then increased competition and lower fares for these airports if you ask me.
jkburns1 is offline