Originally Posted by
dcpatti
The reading lamp complaint always gets under my skin a little. As far as I know, there's no proactive way to tell when a light bulb is ready to burn out, and while I don't know if any airline replaces the light bulbs proactively, it's a moot point, because I think we've all had a dud light bulb at one time or another at home that died after just a fraction of it lifespan. Knowing that a light bulb can burn out at any time, someone who places a high value on having reading light can easily protect themselves against disappointment by carrying a portable reading light. They're small, compact, durable and convenient, and for about $12 on amazon, you remove one of your potential travel nuisances. I'm not sure how it becomes compensation-worthy when it's not worth the passenger applying their own self-help proactively. Same with the spill on the seat: you're sharing a space that several or maybe even dozens of other people use in between deep cleanings, and sometimes we'll find evidence of those other people left behind. Small spills/spill residue and trash in the seat pockets are nuisances but it's the nature of a shared space, just like you might find the table at your local starbucks is a little sticky or has mug rings. Obviously not ideal, but get a napkin and tidy up. (By comparison, some evidence others leave behind is beyond reasonable expectations, so I'm not saying just deal with every situation; only saying it shouldn't go to the frustration and complaint level unless it's more than a simple nuisance.)
OP, the flight attendants sound like they apologized for the nasty sandwich wrap appropriately, and offered the best solution on hand to make the situation better; your request for refund got a response that included the procedure for obtaining this specific type of refund. I don't see what has happened that would cause you to pull your business from any airline over these things; of course, that's always your prerogative. Vote with your dollars. But if you consistently stop flying with a specific airline over nuisance-level issues not being met with compensation, eventually you will run out of airlines to fly.
I respectfully disagree. I don't think it's unreasonable to expect a reading lamp that works, or a clean seat. I think even AA would tell you that is their expectation as well.
Seems AA engineers should be able to engineer a reading lamp that has bulbs that are easily changed. Then the bulb out is no issue, just pop a replacement in.
There are cadres of things that are clearly out of the airlines span of control and responsibility...a clean, functioning cabin should not be one of them.
We as PAX should not roll over and except mediocrity, or we will get sub-mediocrity.