Originally Posted by
ScatterX
My 2.7 cents on this...
1) If it is strong enough to be a cane for a giant person, it could cause significant damage if it could be effectively used as a weapon. See #3.
2) Everything can be used as a weapon. Paper cuts can be lethal.
3) Stick-like weapons inside confined spaces (in all close quarters situations, actually) are almost always LESS EFFECTIVE once they get outside a certain length. Too short is ineffective. Too long is much much less effective. There is a reason that asps, batons, billy clubs, truncheons, and similar are all about the same length. There is a reason the Romans carried swords along with spears (hint: once the enemy was up close, the spear doesn't work so good). This effective length is no where near the length necessary for a really tall person to use as a cane.
4) Light-sabers are no more of a weapon than a soccer ball painted to look like the death star. Only a complete idiot would be afraid of either of these fictional items causing actual "movie-like" damage.
5) TSA's position in this case is idiotic. See #4.
I wonder if we'll see a day when toy drones (non-functional) are banned? After all, some drones carry WMDs...
A kid will be able to carry an unarmed GI Joe toy, but he'll have to give up an armed GI Joe or a toy drone...and if he's a civil war buff, probably a good idea to leave the 1-inch plastic cannon at home, too.