I'm in a situation probably shared by several on this forum. Have 3 AA cards all with 50k sign up bonus with the approximate dates:

AA Visa Platinum 50k -- 10/12
AA AMEX Platinum 50k -- 10/12
AA Bis Visa 50k -- 1/13


Essentially, I'm trying to decide whether to go for:

1) Platinum Select MasterCard 40k (if this is still available to me since my other Plat cards are Visa and AMEX), OR

2) Gold AA Visa Signature Card 25k (since the limited data seems to suggest that this might be more available to current 50k AA card holders?)


I realize there is some beta relevant to this inquiry already contained in the forum, which I have read in it's entirety, but there doesn't seem to be enough to form a consensus. I imagine several people are in my same boat, so if anyone has any advice, or better yet, data based on a similar situation, I would really appreciate hearing it as I've been pressured into doing an churn this week thanks to the 60k Ink and want to figure out which AA card to include...Thanks!