Originally Posted by
echino
Having heard so much praise of the FHR program, I have just tried to make my first reservation for one night at Fairmont Whistler for Canada Day and here's what I learned after speaking to Amex platinum travel:
Lowest FHR rate is $409
Lowest non-FHR rate is $349
Lowest expedia rate is $229
So Amex platinum is completely useless in this particular case.
Not sure whether your non-FHR rate is from Amex or Fairmont, but the FHR is usually competitive with the BAR available directly from the hotel. It does not, and IMO is not designed to, compete with prepaid rates or those offered by third-parties.
Keep in mind that Fairmont does award stay credit for Expedia bookings, so don't let that hold you back from booking that rate.