I'm booking travel for my honeymoon and thought I finally knew what I was doing but once again I feel that the great united laughs in my face.

I'm trying to get 2 tickets from SGN to NYC on July 21 hopefully using award travel. I thought I was doing well booking my trip out, managed to get some supersaver redemptions and life looked good... but getting back its yellow everywhere I turn.

Can anyone help point me in the right direction? Should I dig in on the ANA search page and figure out how to hunt there? Look at some creative routings that I may not have considered? Just give up and spend an insane amount of points to get home? (I'm silver right now, but will be gold by may 19)