Got an email from AC:
We apologize for any confusion pertaining to the terms and conditions of the Earn Your Wings promotion. Similar to the Social Badge, the website should of included a mention to the effect that the Olympic, TCA and Commonwealth badges can only be obtained once. We apologize for this omission and for any inconvenience this may have caused. If you had already booked trips between the promotion's start date of April 11 and April 15, we will honor these bookings based on what was indicated on the website during those days and award you the corresponding amount of wings.
Meh, I'm out.