I am in the wonderful position of trying to choose between the above for a 2 night anniversary trip this may.

Obviously the hotels are not directly comparable, as one is in the middle of a big city (george v), one in a medium sized city but with an adjoining park (fs firenze), one is mostly about eating (le manoir), one is much more expensive (feltrinelli), and two are quite weather dependent (amalfi coast).

However, despite this being a very personal choice, I would welcome any thoughts, and in particular does anyone have recent experiences of Feltrinelli as that is the only one where I feel a little nervous about the hideous cost?

best wishes

BM