Originally Posted by
a1derer
AisleSitter is correct. So what if they cut it off in the wrong place? Just replace the shackle when you get your luggage back ...
If I'm going to do that, then I will purchase my TSA-approved locks (that a motivated TSO could use a special TSA key to unlock - but probably won't). I will buy those locks that have a 'guaranteed replacement' warranty.
I quit doing that because although I never had a problem getting a new lock, it wasn't worth my time. Now I use zip ties. Cheaper and easier to replace and not as tempting.
To some TSOs, the lock sends a message: 'I have something worth stealing, even if you didn't see anything on the x-ray'. I have actually had a lock clipped on a snowboard bag - except the lock was on the zipper pull and the bag was not actually locked. TSA didn't even bother to look - just cut the lock and left it in the bag with a 'love note'.
There's probably a market for these locks with first or very infrequent fliers, or fliers who live/travel abroad. I don't think most domestic US fliers are going to find them more useful than the regular locks that TSOs regularly clip out of laziness.