I can't agree here. Registering an account, posting a rant calling themselves one of AA's best customers to a bunch of other frequent AA travelers and then leaving after the first 5+ people ask questions to ultimately try to help them resolve their issue isn't a discussion. It's not constructive to ask for thoughts/help on a vague situation, be asked questions, and not return to answer them. Especially on a topic (int'l upgrades) that is highly sought after and usually gotten right without issue.

If this forum was built on those kind of posts there wouldn't be a "Reply" button to anything -- and what would be the point of that?