Originally Posted by megalab

I have a lot of miles in both MP and AA, and am top tier elite in both programs so have full access to their best availability. Regardless, in most cases (estimate ~75%) I find better options from MP vs. AA flying out of ORD.

For instance, trying to book a trip to LIM this summer. MP had more options with shorter travel times, including the only r/t option w/o an overnight flight.

While AA can have some good low miles awards, when I do find better flights on AA/OW its for flights with such low ticket prices the redemption value is not really worth it.

For instance, I want to go to NYC next month. No good saver options from MP. I can use the Citi AA reduced mileage awards to HPN (15,750 AA miles r/t). I can also fly AA to LGA for $158 r/t (vs $328 on UA) but 1 cpm is not worth it to me. I'll just pay to fly AA.

Do you own booking comparisons and see if you get similar results.