FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Reclining seatback while plane at gate?
View Single Post
Old Dec 23, 2012 | 10:16 pm
  #45  
nkedel
FlyerTalk Evangelist
30 Countries Visited
2M
All eyes on you!
25 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: in the vicinity of SFO
Programs: AA 2MM (LT-PLT, PPro for this year)
Posts: 19,784
Originally Posted by UA-NYC
IMO you shouldn't be reclining your seat until you're in the air. Everyone around you will still have it upright - you should too.
I always recline the seat briefly (and then, normally, immediately bring it back to vertical) when I first sit down, to check for a broken seat -- plus to have a definite answer that it isn't broken on the rare occasion you get someone intentionally blocking the recline (whether using a device or just their knees.)

I don't normally bring it down on the ground, although I have during extended ground delays. I've twice been caught on board a plane for hours during WX delays (once at SFO in AA domestic F, once in HKG in CX J) and being able to recline made a huge difference in my ability to sleep through them.

Originally Posted by cerealmarketer
What about after taxi / takeoff? When is it appropriate according to FAA? When we hit 10,000 feet and get the double dings, or as soon as the wheels come off the ground?
Having been in an flight with a mechanical failure that required an immediate go-around to the gate (although it was something where we could get back to a gate, and not an evacuation) I always wait for the 10,000 feet ding to recline and take my shoes off. I figure if something were to go wrong which would bring us back to the ground quickly (but in one piece) it would have happened by then.

Originally Posted by Thunderroad
One thing I like a lot about the newer AA 738 F seats is that the seat slides forward as the back reclines
[...]
I don't know whether any Y or other airlines' F cabins have this, but it seems like a good approach to ameliorating or even eliminating the tension over the reclining seat.
The AA 738 F seats are a particularly nice implementation of this; the 738 Y seats do it too, a bit less nicely. The fairly recent, but now outgoing CX Y "shell" seats do, but rather badly (these have a different point of articulation.)
nkedel is offline