Originally Posted by
TimeToEarnMiles
I opt out of the tip surcharges and give on my own. I usually tip the wait staff and room steward. This ensures the people who help me personally get rewarded.
They still have to turn it in to the tipping pool. Anything you give over and above the suggested amount, they get to keep. But just because you only see one waiter doesn't mean there aren't others who are involved in making your experience good, and they get a share regardless if you give cash personally to one person or leave the autotips in place.