How many nights will you be staying. If you're doing a 4 night stay then I think AXON/GLON awards are a decent option. You could do the Amex and Citi Hilton cards and be at 115k points which would put you pretty close to a 4 night award stay for a CAT 5 or 6.

The Hyatt card is not a bad deal either considering you get 2 nights at any Hyatt hotel. They've got some nice properties in NYC.