Well... I got kicked off and wasn't using Auto4Sq...
Like I said, I was checking in using the iPhone app at 3 places each day, spread out at random times. The only thing wrong is I was pushing the checkins quickly so it couldn't get a precise lock on my position and figure out I was 3 miles from the Holiday Inn I was checking in at. Or half a mile from the Doubletree.
Its not that simple.