ALso just back from a 6 day stay at the GH NY. Had a suite on 34 Floor, which was very nice and recently "tuned up".

Absolutely no issue with housekeeping. Everything was in place. I felt a little bad about her, because our housekeeper was at least 65 years old.
did leave a generous tip for here.

Food on Club lounge was very good for US standards, not as good as on european club floors, though.
Breakfest also.
Club attendents were really "not there". No problem for us. No need for them.

The club itself itself is very nice, esp. in summertime

And we DID PAY for beer and wine. Of course you can cheat on them, but thats not our choice.

So overall a very crowded place, but central, was our best stay there overall ( form 10 times)