FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Platinum vs. Diamond
View Single Post
Old Oct 17, 2012, 4:49 pm
  #71  
csdripps
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Philadelphia
Programs: DL - Silver, AA - EXP, Marriott - Platinum Premier
Posts: 200
Originally Posted by tarmac
Thanks for posting this resource. It's great.

My partner and I are both Diamonds and the last four or five flights from JFK - SEA; ATL - SEA/PDX we were not upgraded. We thought for sure that something was amiss. When I tried to check it out, the awards chart said that Diamond Discounted fares upgraded before Platinum fares. This made me wonder if a higher fare platinum would be upgraded. The person I talked with, when I read this, didn't know what it meant. The information she had didn't specifically address my question.
There's another wrinkle, I believe. On Domestic flights (and international flights that do not have BE) a medallion can use a SWU (or 12,500 miles) to move to the top of the list if they are on a Y, B, M, H, Q, or K fare. So theoretically there could be some people ahead of the DM on a Y fare in the upgrade list

DM K fare w/SWU
GM K fare w/12,500 miles

DM Y fare
PM Y fare
GM Y fare
FO Y fare
DM B AMEX Reserve
DM B
DM M Amex Reserve
etc
DM on Award (PNR not attached to lower or non-elite)
PM B Amex Reserve
csdripps is offline