Originally Posted by sdsearch

Well, actually, if you haven't looked at it, the master thread is of "special" offers, rather than "all" offers. So it already does that partially:

http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/miles...er-thread.html (in MilesBuzz!)

It doesn't rank them, but it does provide a starting point for seeing what's around right at this moment (it gets updated as offers get added and as offers expire or are withdrwan). Post 1 has the list that gets updated; the rest of the thread is unimportant (except for history of offers, perhaps) except the latest posts show what changed most recently.

The top 5 offers are not absoute. What is most useful is to get enough miles and points to do something. Applying for a supposedly "top" offer of 70k miles from an ailrine where you have no miles and are not likely to get more miles and the only use you would have would be in 100k mile increaements is not likely to be a top 5 offer for you, but might be for someone who already collects miles with that airlikne in other means and so can top off that 70k to 100k easily. A "top" offer for a hotel program card for a hotel program which does not have properties in the places you travel may be useless to you, even though it may be of great use to someone else who travels to other places.

Thus you can make your own top 5 list, but I don't know if it makes sense to make a top 5 list that covers everyone (especially since these offers come and go constantly, and since the "special" offers list already exiss in the thread I linked).