Originally Posted by
annihilistic
St Johns Pl, or Bedford Ave, Brooklyn.
I'm also entertaining the idea of Manhattan itself. W 173rd St or W 184th St.
Long commutes don't bother me at all, but the idea of switching stations a lot does make me nervous.
Sounds like you're doing Airbnb or something similar? There's nothing in the way of a real hotel in those areas (at least the Manhattan addresses you've cited.)
Be advised that, at least for the Manhattan locations, you might not be in the most wonderful of neighborhoods. I can't speak for the Brooklyn addresses, but I live close enough to Washington Heights to know that area quite well.