Originally Posted by
jackal
Having lived in Alaska for 17 years, I'll dispute what you're saying. On one of the cars I kept for several years, I never bothered to buy studded winter tires and did just fine with the regular all-season radials. I also drove hundreds of rental cars without studded tires and survived quite nicely.
Do studded winter tires help? Certainly, especially during the freeze/thaw/freeze cycle when roads can get covered in glare ice. But if you have a little common sense--drive slower, stop way earlier, leave plenty of room between you and the car in front of you, and avoid stopping on uphill grades of more than a few degrees--you'll do just fine without studs or special winter tires, just like about a third of Alaskans do.

I'd say it depends on where you're driving (very specifically).
You're less likely to need studded tires if you're staying in major brand hotels and visiting just businesses in business parks or downtowns or major tourist sites that also handle tour buses.
But if you're staying with a friend or family member who lives in a hilly district in Northern Virginia with narrow steep streets, where the freeze/thaw/freeze/thaw cycle is very common, and their subdivision gets plowed days after the main streets, studded tires may be
very necessary, because you may not be able to avoid stopping on uphill grades of more than a few degrees (because on those streets, two cars can't pass each other without stopping if people are parked!).
And that's why I said "chain hotels" above. Because chain hotels don't usually locate themselves on hard to navigate "last to be plowed" streets. But indie B&Bs sometimes do. So in New England, I would think it might depend on whether you're going to stay in B&Bs on the outskirts of a hilly town, or only in the chain hotel near the intersection of two major highways.
(I also don't know how much studded tires help in deep snow without freezing, like BUffalo gets with their "lake effect" snow. I grew up in the Northern Virginia area so I'm used to freeze/thaw/freeze/thaw snow, or none at all!)
I too have driven in snow with regular tires taking it very slow and trying to not stop on slopes. And I found it not as horrid as driving in summer mud, actually!

But some locations like many Northern Virigina suburbs of DC have zilions of streets with steep grades with thaw/freeze and with plowing not quick to come to every last residential street, and I bet that's not the only place in North America where that happens (but I don't know how rare it is,
if you need to visit such residential streets on your trip).