Originally Posted by
Stripe
So you're basically saying that being on the same PNR as me gives my companion absolutely no advantage, while at the same time killing my own chances. That's quite a benefit my elite status gets me.

Your companion has a
chance at an upgrade he/she wouldn't have otherwise. That's a considerable advantage over the other non-Medallion passengers on the flight.
Methinks you would also complain if regularly riding in coach because DM's were getting upgraded ahead of you with their non-status companions. (I know I wouldn't like it.) You can't have it both ways.