Originally Posted by
stifle
That was (a) not a fine and (b) a Megatrain ticket, which has its own special conditions

Megatrain tickets have basically the same conditions as Advance tickets - i.e., you must travel on a specific train service to a specific destination, with no break of journey or "stopping short" permitted.
You can argue over terminology, but the fact that they had to pay *double* the prevailing full ticket price, in addition to the ticket they already purchased, makes it a fine in my book.