I'm in the midst of booking a 5 night Seychelles stay in November. The pricing at Banyan Tree is compelling, however the reviews are worrisome. I'm looking for insight as to what the better option would be. Here are the details:

FS: 5 nights Bed & Breakfast plan in garden villa $6,120 (3,786 GBP)

BT: 5 nights Bed & Breakfast plan in
Hillside Pool Villa= $3,827 (2,368 GBP)
Pool Villa by the Rocks= $3,973 (2,458 GBP)
Beachfront Spa Pool Villa= $4,720 (2,920 GBP)

I am traveling with my wife and we'd like to incorporate day trips to Praslin and La Digue as well. Therefore, I'm leaning towards the BT cheaper option as we'll likely be out of the resort a few days. Location seems suitable at each place. Any insight from previous patrons is much appreciated. Also open to alternative options though I'm not inclined to spend much over $1,000 for bed/breakfast only.