FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Air travel would be safer if we allowed knives, lighters and liquids
Old Apr 13, 2012 | 3:36 pm
  #1  
jplondon
All eyes on you!
15 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: London-Nice
Programs: GFL
Posts: 1,451
Air travel would be safer if we allowed knives, lighters and liquids

Interesting WSJ article on airline security! Refreshing views!

Article URL: on.wsj.com/ISMe9W

"Air travel would be safer if we allowed knives, lighters and liquids, says a former head of the TSA"

"Randomize security: Predictability is deadly"

"To be effective, airport security needs to embrace flexibility and risk management—principles that it is difficult for both the bureaucracy and the public to accept. The public wants the airport experience to be predictable, hassle-free and airtight and for it to keep us 100% safe. But 100% safety is unattainable. Embracing a bit of risk could reduce the hassle of today's airport experience while making us safer at the same time.

Over the past 10 years, most Americans have had extensive personal experience with the TSA, and this familiarity has bred contempt. People often suggest that the U.S. should adopt the "Israeli method" of airport security—which relies on less screening of banned items and more interviewing of passengers. But Israeli citizens accept the continued existence of a common enemy that requires them to tolerate necessary inconveniences, and they know that terror plots are ongoing.

In America, any successful attack—no matter how small—is likely to lead to a series of public recriminations and witch hunts. But security is a series of trade-offs. We've made it through the 10 years after 9/11 without another attack, something that was not a given. But no security system can be maintained over the long term without public support and cooperation. If Americans are ready to embrace risk, it is time to strike a new balance."
jplondon is offline