I don't feel comfortable having moderator decisions being scrutinized in an open forum, by people who are not involved in it, and don't seem to comprehend what goes on behind the scenes or seem to understand the history taken into consideration in a decision. IMHO these are issues that should be taken to email to the moderators or Randy. Starting discussions on specific members has never been allowed so I don't see any reason to do so.

And just for the record, in certain decisions we have taken, Randy not only backed us but told us we were being "weak" and should have handed out a one year ban.