Regarding the ongoing thread in the DL forum about moderators (fortunately currently off the first few pages!) -- please don't use that as an argument that other forums should permit the same.

The DL moderators have collectively decided, at least for now, to permit that one off-topic thread to remain open.

* It really does NOT belong in the DL forum. It isn't about Delta or Skymiles. Meta issues regarding FT belong in their designated places -- such as this forum (to get Randy's attention), Suggestions, or the TalkBoard forum.

* The DL moderators are reluctant to close threads critical of ourselves. We are second to none in jumping in when inappropriate, off-topic, or offensive posts are directed at others. But we've developed a bit of a thicker skin with respect to ourselves. By permitting open criticism, we hope to quell some of the distate against moderators and build support for our role in directing discussion towards the topic at hand and putting out fires and flames that detract from the community.

* It is our hope that by channeling criticism of moderators into a single thread we can contain the criticism and prevent it from spilling over onto the board at large.

I should say that the analysis above should be attributed to me only and not the other moderators who might express things a bit differently.

And this strategy may ultimately be misguided. But, for better or worse, that's what we're trying to do.

And as I mentioned above, there is precedent for both anonymous moderation (first two moderators) and moderation without explanation (Randy & Co). It's not my own choice, however.