Originally Posted by
The_Daddy
@Musken: I know it's hard to stick with one :-)! Are you sure about Amanpulo? it is not your opinion influenced by fresh memories? I read you just got back from there!
Originally Posted by
vuittonsofstyle
Impossible to answer - it depends where I have just been to. If pushed, I would say, generically, Aman.

So maybe where I have just been is most important... Maybe I will just have to agree with vuittons? Hmmmm.
At least, if we do it "my way" (rating sub-items rather than the full hotel experience), Aman's would be top of most criteria.... (will not ruin this thread with another of my "best of" votes).