I like the concept of providing a general indication of what I've found, with enough information that someone else can decide if it might apply to him/her, and offering to get into specifics via private e-mail. From what I know of the airline/hotel visitors to these boards, one of whom I know rather well personally, they're not here to clamp down on "loopholes" or anything else, but that can change and there's also the exception.
And I think Punki did us a service by re-starting this thread without the clutter. Thanks!