Originally Posted by
Baze
So you basically stole an upgrade from someone who actually booked the flight you ended up on. If it had been me and I found out about this I would have been very unhappy with UA. If you had paid for C then I would understand but you were also an upgrader on a W fare.
Originally Posted by
Cantheplanegofaster?
+1000
My question is did the OP displace someone on the waitlist with high fare, etc.
If they did, then UA should get smacked in the head for it.
The fac that OP displaced someone else will get paid back via karma

You are both way off base. The OP held a confirmed business class reservation (an upgrade, yes, but still a confirmed business class reservation) and was re-accommodated on another flight, so that he could travel in the class he was booked in.
Sorry, but that is not stealing. How can the OP steal something that never belonged to anyone on the NRT upgrade waitlist? DO you really think if I am #1 on the waitlist, the upgrade already belongs to me? It does not.