FlyerTalk is the only Bulletin Board I (ever) activly participate.
This very limited personal experience doesn't allow me to judge about feasabilities of many proposals and I can even less guess the probable outcome.
I admire the work svpii did put into the proposal which, on/with my limited first sight, looks convincing - at the same time I am sure, that personally I would never want and accept (the responsability) to be a moderator of any FlyerTal-board/forum.
I am very interested to hear more PRO and CONTRAS to the proposals to enable me to make a better personal judgement on the issue.