I'm booking Denver to Toledo with points and then purchasing coach from Toledo to Cleveland on the Lake Shore Limited. The reason, of course, is that it costs 10000 more AGR points to keep the bedroom from Toledo to Cleveland. I'm guessing there is a good chance no one is getting on that sleeper at 2:50 am and purchasing the bedroom from Toledo to New York or Boston, so I think my chances are pretty good of negotiating a reasonable price to stay in the sleeper from Toledo to Cleveland.

Anyone out there have experience with this particular upgrade? I love suggestions about how to present my request and keep the price as low as possible. Two more hours in a bedroom are not worth the $260 or 10,000 point list price.