Commuter
etravel sounds like he works on Madison Avenue---The are both good clubs but they are still just airport clubs not luxury restaurants or country clubs. As Chiangi says you can visit both clubs to see. They will stamp your club invitation if you ask with the "Permission to Renter Stamp" and you can go back and forth as long as you keep your next flight leg coupon in your pocket. You can also take the moving sidewalk from one concourse to another to get rid of any DVT from those long flights if you don't want to try to navigate the elevator/tram thing. The F class rest in the Wing is better I think than the Wing. Also note Wing is upstairs while Pier is down---