Originally Posted by
Henry82
I really think this is a worthy discussion in light of the upcoming Continental/UA merger since after Sept 2011, UA vs US Air will be the only two choices for U.S.-based *A FFP's. Let's compare/contrast in terms of:
1) Earning potential via flights on original carrier
Slight advantage to UA due to strategically positioned coastal hubs that allow for longer routings. 1P's 100% bonus (which seems to be going away soon) is also good, but like I said is destined to disappear.
2) Earning potential via flights on alliance partners
More or less equal
3) Earning potential via non-flights (Shopping Portal, partners, etc.)
Essentially negligible but IME slight advantage to US
4) Award redemption on original carrier
Advantage to UA, US envoy awards are pretty hard to get
5) Award redemption on *A partners
Advantage to US, no Starnet blocking, looser routing rules and more generous award chart.
6) Low/Mid/High tier status benefits
As US silvers definitely have the edge over UA 2P in terms of UDU and everything- because US' elite pool is not as bloated as UA's