FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Do flight attendants really hate us?
View Single Post
Old Aug 11, 2011 | 9:43 am
  #68  
Darbs
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Posts: 35
Originally Posted by BearX220
She works a ten-hour day, 30 weeks a year? How terrible for her. Perhaps she would prefer to work a twelve-hour day 49 weeks a year, like a lot of the rest of us.

Does she have to go out and drum up her own students / customers? Does her pay go down if her students do poorly on tests? Does she face any performance reviews at all that could affect her career? Does she have to work Christmas morning or the Fourth of July? Does she have to make strategic decisions, hire and fire personnel, meet quotas, or face having her job outsourced to India?

No?

Comparatively sweet deal. I wonder if she'd like to be put on commission: $200 a week, plus $100 every time a student aces the SAT. If the kids don't learn, she doesn't eat. I doubt she'd take that bet because her current arrangement insulates her from risk almost completely.

That cozy situation is one FAs and teachers alike are loath to give up. I will always remember the ill-fated employee buyout of United Airlines, years ago. Of all the worker groups, only the FAs wanted no part of it, even though the upside of the deal would have been dramatic. They wanted minimum risk and responsibility, even though it meant lower compensation. And they never stopped complaining.

With stratospheric unemployment, though, complaining ought to be going out of style. As this country goes over the falls, we ought to learn to start counting our blessings.
Every teacher I know faces performance evaluations at the end of every year. This is based on how well their kids do on standardized tests, in the classroom, as well as student behavior. Their pay can and does go down if they aren't meeting their requirements in these areas. However, it does NOT go up if they exceed these quotas, nor is their a bonus. Just like the school's funding goes down if they don't meet their state requirements. And with school funding at an all time low, most teachers have 0 job security. School systems in the state of Georgia are laying off teachers every year and not filling those positions.

I don't think teaching is a "cozy situation" and I don't think you can even come close to comparing teachers to FAs. What did some other commenter say, FAs just serve up diet cokes? Teachers have a lot more responsibility than serving a few drinks.

Maybe we should just not compare FAs to other jobs and judge them based on their own merit.
Darbs is offline