Same here! But I don't think any of mine have been stolen yet.

AirForceFlyer, packing in all 5 Indonesia Amans is logistically possible, but I'm not sure it would be a satisfying experience - you might end up longing to stay more at each property. If I were you, I'd pick one out of Amankila and Amanusa (my personal preference is for Amanusa, but I think I'm in the minority here. You could flip a coin; they're both fabulous) since they're beachy properties with no pronounced "theme". I'd certainly do Amanjiwo - it stands out for its uniqueness and for me it's decisively the best of the 5. Unless you really like water activities, esp. snorkeling and/or diving, I'd pick Amandari, again for its uniqueness. Completely agree with Ericka on Amanwana. I've seen better tented properties, prettier islands, and better waters and snorkeling than Amanwana - although the combination of the 3 at Amanwana is formidable.

I don't think a day trip from Amanusa to Kila and Dari would be worth it for the amount of time it would take you. If you haven't visited Bali before, I'd highly recommend spending time instead on any of the following activities, depending on your interests: visiting temples, beaches, restaurants, local dance performances, hikes or bike rides around rice paddy fields, etc.